Which plumbers ChatGPT recommends, and why

We asked ChatGPT to recommend plumbers in 10 major cities, 60 times in all. Each answer shows a map of local businesses and features about 5. Featured plumbers had a median of 274 reviews. The ones it passed over had 43.

Checked Sept 23, 2026

What gets a business featured

Out of 696 map listings across all answers, ChatGPT featured 244. Each chart shows how often a listing was featured, split by one trait at a time.

By number of reviews

under 25 11% 187
25 to 99 22% 158
100 to 499 51% 255
500 or more 60% 96
Featured rate, on a 0 to 100% scale (the faint line is 50%). The last column is how many map listings fell in each group.

By star rating

under 4.0 18% 148
4.0 to 4.6 32% 131
4.7 to 4.8 48% 126
4.9 or 5.0 39% 291
Featured rate, on a 0 to 100% scale (the faint line is 50%). The last column is how many map listings fell in each group.

By website

has a website 36% 671
no website 12% 25
Featured rate, on a 0 to 100% scale (the faint line is 50%). The last column is how many map listings fell in each group.

By distance from downtown

under 5 miles 46% 278
5 to 15 miles 29% 366
15 miles or more 21% 52
Featured rate, on a 0 to 100% scale (the faint line is 50%). The last column is how many map listings fell in each group.

Read plainly: the biggest jump is from under 100 reviews (22% featured) to 100 or more (51% to 60%). A perfect rating does not win on its own: 4.9 to 5.0 stars were featured 39% of the time, 4.7 to 4.8 stars 48%. Closer to downtown helps (46% within 5 miles, 21% beyond 15). A featured business's own website was cited in only 7% of its answers, so the website seems to count as part of the listing, not as a source.

City by city

CityFeatured most oftenAnswersListings seenRepeat overlap
New York City NYC Plumbing Services /Mentor Mechanical, Taylor Group Plumbing, Heating, Mechanical & Sprinkler 62435%
Los Angeles Cali Rooter & Plumbing, 911 Plumbing Services 63439%
Chicago J Sewer & Plumbing, Rescue Plumbing 61760%
Dallas Tide Turners Plumbing, Plumbing Unit 61843%
Houston Texas Quality Plumbing, H-Town Plumbers 62371%
Atlanta Atlanta Plumbing & Drain, Fix & Flow Plumbing Co. 61856%
Washington, DC Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup, Haynes Plumbing 61093%
Philadelphia East Philly plumbing & heating llc, Plumbing Pals 62942%
Miami Main Plumbing Services, SOS 24/7 Plumbing Corp 61466%
Phoenix Robins Plumbing, Inc, The Aussie Plumber 61780%

Repeat overlap is how much of the featured list stayed the same when the exact question was asked again.

The websites ChatGPT cites for plumbers

SiteTypeAnswers citing it
expertise.comLocal "best of" list35 of 60
consumeraffairs.comLocal "best of" list24 of 60
angi.comDirectory10 of 60
rotorooter.comBusiness's own site10 of 60
profindr.comLocal "best of" list9 of 60
bestprosintown.comLocal "best of" list7 of 60
bestinhood.comLocal "best of" list4 of 60
reviews.birdeye.comDirectory3 of 60
dfwprofessionals.comLocal "best of" list3 of 60
simonsplumbingaz.comBusiness's own site3 of 60

Common questions

How does ChatGPT choose which plumbers to recommend?

In our 60 answers, featured plumbers had far more reviews than the ones left out (median 274 vs 43). Businesses without a website were rarely featured, and ones closer to downtown were featured more often. A top star rating mattered less than review count.

Which websites does ChatGPT use to recommend plumbers?

The sites it cited most were expertise.com, consumeraffairs.com, angi.com.